Editorials

The Best Of 2005 - Top 20 Albums

Scroll >>

No.20 Between The Buried And Me - Alaska

Alaska is nuts, but frequently brilliant. Few bands cover so much ground, and fewer still do it with such cohesion between what are often considered mutually exclusive styles. BTBAM somehow manage to seamlessly combine often unfathomably complex and brutal tech metal rhythms with spectacularly melodic pop chord progressions, simultaneously nailing just about every metal sub-genre in between with consistent and dazzling ingenuity. Add the staggeringly gorgeous guitar arpeggios which are almost a BTBAM trademark, and you have the only album of the year that makes sense when you’re REALLY fucked up about things. DS
 

No.19 Bearsuit - Team Ping Pong


 
Instead of trying to describe what Bearsuit sound like to my friends (scientists have recently discovered it's actually impossible), I've taken to playing them Team Ping Pong to set them straight. Providing handy examples of all of the multitude of facets to Bearsuit's unique and varying sound, it ranges from cacophonous maelstroms of flutes, guitars, keyboards and percussion to thoughtful and understated melodies and lyrics. Team Ping Pong shows exactly why Bearsuit are a band which, if this world is just in any way, should make even bigger waves in 2006. JH

No.18 Pelican - The Fire In Our Throats Will Beckon The Thaw

Intense and epic soundscapes are what Pelican do best, and this album is no different. Well actually it is, and although introducing acoustic elements into their music was a risk, it paid off big style. This is the band’s best work to date, melting beautiful melodies with extreme riffage. Heavier than Rik Waller in a coat of lead and mellower than flower picking with a hippy, if you don’t like Pelican, you’re either insane or dead. JB
 

No.17 Bright Eyes - I’m Wide Awake its Morning

 
One of two Bright Eyes albums in 2005 (not counting the live one), I’m Wide Awake it’s Morning managed to encapsulate almost everything Conor Oberst has to offer. Considerably more measured than on previous albums, Oberst kept one eye on his musical integrity while attracting a whole new audience. Without a single weak track, highlights range from the heartbroken resignation of ‘Landlocked Blues’ to the riotous political rant of closer ‘Road To Joy’. Another year spent adding to an already bulging repertoire of celebrated songs, and he’s still only 25. Bastard. RS

No
.
16 Envelopes - Demon


Despite my somewhat shallow misgivings about bands naming themselves after something found in a stationery cupboard, Envelopes provided the year’s summer soundtrack for me and many other satisfied customers. This eclectic wedge of Scandinavian pop trawls the indie seas, netting influences from Pixies, Pavement and Belle and Sebastian and presenting its catches in a way that merits a mention in such revered company. Demon is a ray of sunshine from a place that often sees little of the stuff (I'm talking about York, where they've been recording their new album). Listen and smile. JH
 

No
.
15 Twin Zero - Monolith


 
There’s little doubt Twin Zero’s sophomore effort (due 2006) will raise the bar for metal even further, but Monolith got 2005 off to an epic, Armageddon-inducing start. Unleashing a feast of pounding rhythms, Karl Middleton (earthtone9)’s soaring and searing vocal attack and oodles of ideas, Monolith is at times both life-affirmingly triumphant and brain-crushingly destructive. And as it’s basically one piece of music, what you’ve got is essentially nigh on forty minutes of whale-heavy riffs and beautiful atmospheric interludes to give your head a damn good seeing to. DS

No
.
14 Zark Behida - Isis


Zark takes us on a seat-of-the-pants ride through a turbulent drum and bass landscape, with a suggested serving including big speakers and the album's accompanying book. Isis veers carefully between typical dnb and more experimental broken beats territory, never being straight-forward, never too manic. This album can certainly be numbered as one of the most satisfying electronic offerings over the last year, ticking both the energetic and profound boxes on the Standard Review Form N36. SR
 

No
.
13 Animal Collective - Feels


 
Any band that consists of four members named Geologist, Avey Tare, Panda Bear and Deacon are automatically fine by me. And when they produce wondrous, swirling, subtly complex pop songs such as the nine found on Feels, they cannot fail to stay ingrained on the brain for quite some time. No other album this year has managed to sit eccentricity so comfortably with sincerity. Feels may not grab you at the first listen, but give it the time it deserves and it will never be far from your stereo. RS

No
.
12 British Sea Power - Open Season


2003’s The Decline of British Sea Power was a fine album, but put some listeners off with its more ‘out there’ tendencies. The complex, epic Open Season saw BSP pull off a more accessible and obviously melodic album without sacrificing any of their uniqueness. It’s hard to think of another contemporary band who could come up with song titles as good as ‘It Ended On An Oily Stage’; whose idiosyncratic lyrics and artwork make frequent reference to the Great Outdoors; or whose flora-strewn gigs culminate with the band being beaten up by a man in a bear costume. I love this band and I plan to marry it. MB
 

No
.11 Marmaduke Duke - The Magnificent Duke


 
Marmaduke Duke (although they should really be known as Biffy Sly-ro for the sneaky concealment of Biffy front-man Simon Neil) fire off volley after volley of staccato alternative rock in this first of a trilogy of fables. The Duke may well be the evil twin brother of Biffy, with a keyboard in his bag of tricks and a sneer on his face. If you’re fed up of character-less music with as much emotion as Neil Hamilton, get hold of The Duke and he’ll show you what excitement and extravagance is all about. SA

No
.10 Million Dead - Harmony No Harmony


Alas, I once again write a TinyVoices Top 20 entry more as an epitaph than a review. Million Dead took the rather shaky and preposterous idea of British post-hardcore and ran with it – and by the time of this, only their second album, had completely reinvented the form. Adding wider influences from the Smiths to Soundgarden into their wired punk-rock ire, Harmony No Harmony saw Million Dead poised for deserved recognition as one of the UK’s most imaginative and talented rock bands. Only no-one bought their album and they broke up instead. Bollocks. TP
 

No
.9 Innocent Cabbage - Innocent Cabbage


 
How Innocent Cabbage are not now every metalhead teenager’s favourite band is beyond me. This, their first real album, is 33 minutes packed full of massively atmospheric riffs and the kind of screaming that gets you sectioned under the Mental Health Act. Throw in some of the best metal song-writing in recent memory, a stupidly talented drummer and a madcap ("You care / You love me / I am so beautiful / Feel my nipple") but often shrewdly-observed sense of humour, and the end result is possibly the best metal album of the noughties so far. WM

No.8 Reuben - Very Fast Very Dangerous


Confidently leading the British Emocore (or whatever it’s called these days) scene, Reuben return with their second LP, and their first written from scratch. A quantum leap in production quality (Chris Sheldon has worked with Biffy Clyro and Foo Fighters) allows Reuben to really show off their energy. It’s all here – the down-tuned riffery, the melodies, the powerhouse rhythm section and more scringing (that’s the rapid switch between singing and screaming) than you could care to wave a stick, a badger, or any other wavy thing at. WM
 

No
.7 dEUS - Pocket Revolution


 
Lamarr isn’t the only one who feels there’s not much justice in the world. If there was any justice in the world, dEUS would be huge. On their first album since 1999’s awesome The Ideal Crash Tom Barman and co serve up a masterclass of songwriting and inventiveness. From blistering opener ‘Bad Timing’ to the sublime jazz-pop of ‘Nothing Really Ends’ dEUS show that nothing is beyond them. Despite the scope of their sound, perhaps dEUS’ greatest trick is to never let their ecclecticism overshadow the fact they have great tunes. JD

No.6 Coheed And Cambria - Good Apollo I’m Burning Star


This, the third album from prog-emo superstars Coheed and Cambria, was even better than we expected, taking the best parts of their last two brilliant albums and forging the finest record to emerge from that already-stale scene. Claudio Sanchez’s Geddy Lee-inspired vocals add stunning melody to the awe-inspiring music. C&C are sounding more and more like Pink Floyd each day, and while this album is already their best, you can’t help feeling their greatest work is still to come. JB
 

5. Art Brut - Bang Bang Rock and Roll


 
Look at them, they formed a band. Bang Bang Rock and Roll instantly blew away all accusations that Art Brut were a flash-in-the-pan one-joke band. From rocking out to modern art, bungling a heist and painfully (and hilariously) recounting an attack of Mr Floppy ("Don’t tell your friends!"), front man Eddie Argos hits all-time highs of quotability with his seemingly effortless absurdisms and self-effacing one-liners ("and yes, this is my singing voice"). But the amped up garage rock knocked out by the rest of the band deserves equal credit in achieving the seemingly impossible – making a credible and durable rock album full of brilliantly funny moments. An addictive, deliciously wry album from a gloriously out-of-kilter band. TP

No
.
4 Oceansize - Everyone Into Position


Can this album really be as great as I said it was when I first reviewed it? Yes, actually. True, it’s meandering and epic, and really quite self-indulgent in places, but ultimately Everyone Into Position has so much depth and subtelty, and so many brilliant ideas, that I can’t really fault it. It’s well-crafted in a way that almost nothing else is these days, a lesson in dynamics, suspense and release, glorious, rampaging heaviness and fragile, melodic splendour. Am I allowed to say that this is the pinnacle of guitar music? (It is). DS
 

No
.
3 Sigur Ros - Takk


 
After the near unrelenting menace of ( ), the Ros returned in 2005 showing off their more euphoric side. Their enourmous sound is still unique, and it still doesn’t matter if, like myself, you don’t have a clue what Jonsi is singing about, as the overall effect is just so beguiling and dazzling. First single ‘Glosoli’ is pretty much a microcosm for the whole album, combining gentle atmospheres with overwhelming noise to geniunely rousing effect. A great band for whom there aren’t sufficient superlatives. JD

No
.
2 System Of A Down - Hypnotize / Mezmerize


This dual album release from the Serbian superstars may be insane, but luckily, as is often the case, the insanity is twinned with genius. Who else combines folk with metal and actually makes it sound good? Singer Serj Tankian’s political ruminations may perhaps be too subtle for the average SOAD fan, but the honourable task of enlightenment is saddled in outlandishly spectacular manner. No other band today provides the masses with rock music as eccentric and entertaining as this. SA
 

No
.
1 Arcade Fire - Funeral

 
Musically, if not in any other sense, Canada has some pretty horrific skeletons rattling around its national closet: Adams, Dion, Barenaked Ladies… Arcade Fire’s debut album – released in the UK in 2005 – went some way towards compensating for these historical nightmares. While comparisons to the likes of Bowie and Talking Heads abounded (as comparisons are wont to do), Funeral carved out a distinctive sound of its own: baroque, intricate, multi-layered and simultaneously dark and joyous. In what was a very good year for music, Arcade Fire fully deserve their highly coveted position here and their current status as darlings of the indie-pop universe. Oh, and when they did ‘Rebellion (Lies)’ on Top of the Pops, it rocked. MB

more...